- Departmental Seminars
- Casebooks Therapy
- Philosophy of Psychology and Psychiatry Reading Group
- Early Science and Medicine Work-in-Progress
Departmental Seminars: Virtual Conversations
During Easter Term we are holding a special series of virtual conversations on the relevance of the history and philosophy of science for the 21st century.
All events take place on Thursdays from 3.30pm to 5pm UK time (except for the one on 7 May, which starts at 4pm). They will all be held on Zoom.
Organised by Dániel Margócsy (dm753).
7 May at 4pm
Pandemic and Policy
The threats of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, and the effectiveness and harms of the social policies meant to mitigate these threats, rapidly became the most important scientific issues in many years. This session will analyse the pandemic and policy response from a variety of angles. Topics will include the nature and empirical basis for the relevant epidemiological models, the difficulties with exporting policies out of European contexts, and the challenges of democratic citizen science in a context of lay conspiratorial skepticism of science.
Speakers: Elizabeth Anderson (University of Michigan – Ann Arbor), Alexander Broadbent (University of Johannesburg), Eric Winsberg (University of South Florida)
Chair: Jacob Stegenga
14 May
Histories of Medicine for the 21st Century
Historians of medicine study numerous periods and places, traditions of healing, and kinds of knowledge and practice. What does this rich and diverse field contribute towards analyzing, critiquing and shaping concerns about health, health care, and society in the 21st century? This panel brings together four scholars with widely differing areas of expertise to build connections across time, place and methods, and discuss what history of medicine has to offer for the 21st century.
Speakers: Lauren Kassell (University of Cambridge), Projit Bihari Mukharji (University of Pennsylvania), Ahmed Ragab (Harvard University), Dora Vargha (University of Exeter)
Chair: Dániel Margócsy
21 May
Legacies of Early Modern Colonial Science
How was natural knowledge made in colonial encounters across the early modern period? How did natural knowledge contribute to the construction of racial and ethnic difference? And how did the process of colonization reconfigure the concept of knowledge? This panel examines how the 21st-century world continues to be shaped by the answers that early modern peoples provided to these questions.
Speakers: Maria Portuondo (Johns Hopkins University), Simon Schaffer (University of Cambridge), Suman Seth (Cornell University)
Chair: Dániel Margócsy
28 May
Calculating Trust
Trust is a central category in the social history of science and philosophy of scientific practice. It is far from obvious that trust should be placed in the veracity and relevance of scientific claims in political decision processes, especially if one keeps in mind that scepticism and pluralism are sometimes highly valued by scientists themselves. This virtual conversation will question the epistemological, cultural and political settings that generate trust in knowledge claims, or else lead to its breakdown. Particular attention will be paid to disciplines that rely on statistical modelling, since these can be seen as trading in uncertainty and the calculability of trust.
Speakers: Stephanie Dick (University of Pennsylvania), Sabina Leonelli (University of Exeter), Staffan Müller-Wille (University of Cambridge), Ted Porter (UCLA)
Chair: Dániel Margócsy
4 June
Central European Science in Perspective
The Central Europe of around 1900 saw the emergence of significant elements of modern physics, the environmental sciences and psychology. This seminar investigates the particular political, cultural and social geographies of this region and how these geographies have shaped and may still influence the trajectories of these scientific disciplines. What are the connections between Einstein's physics, late 19th-century understandings of madness and rationality, and the cultural politics of the German and Habsburg Empires?
Speakers: Holly Case (Brown University), Michael Gordin (Princeton University), Richard Staley (University of Cambridge)
Chair: Dániel Margócsy
11 June
Citizen Science
Recent decades have seen pleas and initiatives for public participation in science as a way of increasing the trustworthiness of knowledge production and making it more accountable. Three speakers examine central issues surrounding citizen science, democratisation and trust from the perspectives of sociology, epistemology and philosophy of science.
Speakers: Jennifer Gabrys (University of Cambridge), Axel Gelfert (TU Berlin), Inkeri Koskinen (Tampere University)
Chair: Tim Lewens
Casebooks Therapy
Organiser: Lauren Kassell
'Casebooks Therapy' is an informal reading group for those interested in using the manuscripts of Simon Forman and Richard Napier in their research.
The aim of the reading group is to improve the palaeography skills of those who attend, as well as to provide guidance about how to make sense of Forman's and Napier's records. No familiarity with early modern handwriting is necessary, and the group is open to all. Attendees are invited to suggest a particular page or case from the casebooks that they have trouble reading to work through collaboratively.
We will meet on Thursdays at 5.30–7.30pm (BST), beginning with 7 May, 21 May and 4 June. Meetings will take place on Zoom.
If you are interested in taking part, please email Lauren Kassell (ltk21).
Philosophy of Psychology and Psychiatry Reading Group
Tuesdays at 3pm on MS Teams. Organised by Riana Betzler and Sahanika Ratnayake.
Week 1 – 28 April
- 'Illness as dis-ability and health within illness' (Chapter 3) in Carel, H. Illness: The Cry of the Flesh, Acumen, 2008
- The Soul in Depression, On Being (podcast), 2018
Week 2 – 5 May
- Saks R., 'Successful and Schizophrenic', New York Times, 2013
- Wang, E. W., 'Who gets to be the "Good Schizophrenic"?' Buzzfeed Reader 2016. A version of this essay is also printed as 'High Functioning' in Wang's The Collected Schizophrenias, Penguin, 2019.
Week 3 – 12 May
- 'On Narrative Medicine' (Chapter 8) in Solomon, M. Making Medical Knowledge, Oxford University Press, 2015
Week 4 – 19 May
- Fuchs, T. 'Depression, Intercorporeality,and Interaffectivity,' Journal of Consciousness Studies, 2013
Week 5 – 26 May
- Introduction and Chapter 1 ('The World of Depression') in Ratcliffe, M., Experiences of Depression: A Study in Phenomenology, Oxford University Press, 2015
Early Science and Medicine Work-in-Progress
This is a termly forum, supported by Wellcome, for early career scholars to discuss their work-in-progress. We usually discuss two pieces of work at each session.
If you would like to participate, please email the organisers, Justin Rivest (jr723) and Carolin Schmitz (cs2003).
Meetings are held at the start of each term. This term's is on Tuesday 21 April 2020, 5–8pm.
Convened by Lauren Kassell, Silvia De Renzi (OU) and Dániel Margócsy.